An Open Letter to Violent Muslim Protestors

By Imam Abdullah Antelpi  HuffPo

We witnessed another violent and tragic set of events in reaction to the most recent Quran burning scandal by NATO soldiers in Afghanistan and the dust has yet to settle. Violent protests continue in different parts of the country and several civilians have lost their lives. In our recent history, we have seen several similar violent Muslim reactions when some Muslims feel Westerners have insulted and attacked their sacred images or values. The tragic reactions to Salman Rushdie’s “The Satanic Verses,” an infamous Danish cartoon and its bloody consequences, an insignificant Florida pastor’s foolish but costly Quran burning show and more. This column is an honest and sincere call to the Muslims who took and have been taking part in these kinds of violent protests.

Fellow brothers and sisters in Islam who, through whatever means, got involved or are planning to get involved in these kinds of violent protests: As an Imam and, more importantly, as a believing, practicing Muslim, I can’t help but think, “what’s wrong with the Muslims who are involved in violent reactions regardless of the nature or enormity of the offense and insult?” There may be some psychological, political or even cultural explanations (which I will not waste any space discussing in this column) for these primitive and violent responses, but I believe there can be no Islamic, religious, ethical or moral justifications for your excessive, lawless and destructive way of expressing disapproval and hurt. Therefore, I condemn and shun all past and recent Muslim reactions with the strongest possible disapproval and dismay. Shame on you!

These violent reactions of yours really do not make sense on many different fronts. For any Muslim who believes the sacredness of the Quran as God’s final revelation to humanity, that very same Quran condemns and rejects such anarchy in many of her verses and teachings. First of all, the Quran invites us to respect and engage with her divine message more so than the actual physical form of the book that is found between two covers. Respecting a physical copy of Quran could be understandable, but violating its central teachings and principles–for example by killing innocent people–just because someone disrespected or insulted a copy of the Quran is unacceptable, barbaric and reprehensible. No physical copy of a holy scripture, including the Quran, is more sacred than the life of a human being. This is what the Quran and our beloved prophet, whom the Quran came through, teaches us over and over.

Secondly, what do many Muslims throughout the Muslim world do when the copies of the Quran get really worn down and become unusable? We burn them! Yes, you didn’t read it wrong: It is a common Muslim practice to respectfully burn old Qurans when they are no longer reparable. It is proclaimed all over the world, including Afghanistan, in many different interpretations of Islamic law that this is an honorable farewell to these old copies of the Quran. So how do you justify your shameless reactions to Quran burning?

Moreover, these unacceptable and indefensible responses only serve to confirm the fabricated, monstrous and scary image of Islam as a religion and Muslims as a people to the fearful world. I really don’t understand how my fellow Muslims do not see that, with their reactions, they actually prove what has been said about them by their enemies. You call my religion evil or terrorism and, in order to “disprove” this insult, I will go kill people, burn embassies, act like a bloodthirsty crazy person…. Don’t you fellow Muslims see the ridiculousness of this logic and actions! The uncivilized images of these violent protests by these irresponsible and violent Muslims shape the image of 1.6 billion Muslims all around the world. These images are so powerful that even education and exposure to real Islam later on is unable to remove these images from the hearts and minds of many non-Muslims.

Maybe more importantly, Muslims themselves are not immune to the images of these ugly and violent scenes created by fellow Muslims. Seeing the actions of Muslim extremists over and over on a daily basis increasingly causes Muslim internalization of biased anti-Muslim propaganda. This creates an atmosphere of perception that all of the world’s extremists are Muslims. Do these angry Muslim protesters not realize how much harm and destruction they do to Islam and to their fellow Muslims all over the world?! Or how much pain and embarrassment they inflict on fellow believers?

Finally, my dear fellow Muslims, you may be thinking that you have been defending Islam and Muslims against their enemies through these violent protests. May God bless you with enough common sense and wisdom to realize that, by protesting in this manner, you are being the worst and most destructive enemies of Islam.

Time for a Little Honesty: Sometimes Muslims Burn Qurans

Dr. David Liepert posted on HuffPo

Twenty years ago, back in the “good old days,” when Rambo still fought alongside the Mujahedeen in Hollywood and Osama bin Laden still worked in Afghanistan for the U.S. Department of State, I discovered I had a problem.
Back then, as a newly “reverted” Muslim, whenever I went to the mosque, people kept handing me leaflets, advertisements and calendars with snippets of the Arabic Quran on them. And although they meant well, pretty soon, those leaflets started to pile up at home: because although I realized I couldn’t just throw them out in the garbage like any other trash, I didn’t know what else to do!

However, when I brought my conundrum to the imam I learned the answer was actually an easy one with a long scholarly tradition to support it. He told me the most respectful way to deal with God’s message to Muslims — in it’s original Arabic format — was to burn the paper and ink it was delivered with, and give God’s message back to God.

So when Quran burning first hit the popular media a few years back, I have to admit I didn’t really understand what the problem was. Obviously, someone idiotic enough to want to burn God’s message to God’s servants without even reading it wasn’t going to respect it, no matter what else he did with it: I figured sending it back to our shared Creator was the probably the wisest thing he would ever do!

So despite the heat of current controversy surrounding the U.S. Army’s recent attempt to burn old Qurans in Afghanistan, if Muslims are being honest, we’ll admit that burning them is one of the ways Muslims discard old “well-used” Qurans, too.

Granted it’s not preferable: Qurans deserve better treatment than short snippets of phrase, and so an honorable burial, or being sunk to the bottom of a running stream, is better. Regardless, it’s not the paper or the ink that really matters, it’s the message those words deliver that Muslims love the most. And to honor that message, when the vessel that contains it no longer proves adequate to God’s purpose of high-fidelity transmission, we give it back to God.

However, a better way to honor it is to actually live by it, and frankly, that’s where we seem to be falling short these days. Now, don’t get me wrong. I understand why Muslims get upset with non-Muslims disrespecting our religion. But the thing is, our religion has very specific advice about what to do when that happens! And no-where does it say we’re supposed to kill or be killed!

Instead, even though honor mattered to pre-Muslim Arabs in Muhammad’s day as much as it seems to matter to Muslims today again, since it didn’t matter one whit to Muhammad back then, it still shouldn’t matter to Muslims now at all.

He told his followers very specifically that his honor wasn’t worth getting hurt for, and even with an army behind him he wasn’t willing to fight for it himself: In fact, while Muhammad was alive he brought the way Arabs worshiped honor over life to a crashing end. Don’t believe me? Check out what happened at Hudaybiyyah. Because what happened there brought peace to the Middle East for Muslim and non-Muslim alike, which was one of the main purposes of Muhammad’s Islam.

Now it seems we’re back to where we started: Our world is being torn apart by tribal, national and religious chauvinism, just like it was being torn apart back then. However, the good news is, Muslims generally figure that what worked back then should still work today, right?

So, when someone burns a Quran, what should Muslims do? I don’t think anyone’s said it any better than Sheikh Ibrahim Mogra, who chairs the mosques and community affairs committee of the Muslim Council of Britain:

“What is captured on the pages can be printed again. If they burn 1,000, we can print 10,000. What’s the big deal? … A NATO soldier killing innocent people is far more painful than the burning of a Quran. I would rather they burn 100 Qurans than to hurt one woman or man or child.”

And that’s the message we should be focused on, because it’s not just the Muslims who aren’t following their book, it’s everyone else too. America today, despite invading Iraq and Afghanistan, an invasion that’s resulted in the deaths of tens of thousands of innocent men, women and children for the sake of vengeance and American security still considers itself a “Christian” nation. And didn’t Jesus once say something about turning the other cheek?

And while we’re at it, God was pretty clear in the beginning, that He was putting the Jews in charge of the Holy Land because they’d bring God’s benevolent Justice, and God’s benevolent Peace to all people’s living there, something the Quran confirms.

Israel wants security, and Palestine wants justice. Judaism and Islam, on the other hand, both say you’re not following either religion until you want for your neighbor what you want for yourself.

Enough said?

So while like every other Muslim out there I honestly believe that Muhammad’s Islam holds the answer for everyone, it’s not like you might think, if you don’t know Muhammad like I know Muhammad.

Because if you go by the actual record of what he did, rather than the rhetoric that surrounds it, Muhammad didn’t bring God’s peace by making everyone live up to Muslim standards. No, he made everyone live up to their own standards instead: He made Christians be better Christians, he made Jews be better Jews, and he made Muslims be better Muslims.

So what he did? Well, I think that’s what we should do too.

And enough about Qur’an burning!